Measuring progress. Inspiring action.

December 2013

All Kids Ready for Kindergarten: New Report Card Shows Income and Racial Disparities Threaten Reaching Goal by 2020

Reprinted from the Wilder Foundation blog, December 5.

By Richard Chase, Senior Research Manager, Wilder Research

Our infants, toddlers, and preschoolers have the distinction of being the most racially and ethnically diverse Minnesotans. Children of color now make up about 30 percent of the 420,000 children under age 6.

school readiness graph

Something is fundamentally wrong, however, because our youngest children are also the poorest Minnesotans. Nearly one in five children under age 6 lives in poverty, and 61 percent of children under age 6 living in poverty are children of color. They also suffer disparity after disparity in indicators of educational, health, and social well-being, which place their own and our state’s future prosperity at risk.

A new School Readiness Report Card prepared by Wilder Research for the Minnesota Office of Early Learning shows the systemic challenges that begin before birth:

Access to prenatal care is lower for mothers of color. Adequacy of prenatal care can affect birth outcomes, such as birth weight, which in turn affect healthy development. In 2011, 78 percent of births were to mothers who received adequate or better prenatal care. However, the share of mothers of color with adequate or better prenatal care is 12 to 37 percentage points lower than white mothers, with American Indians having the lowest percentage, 46 percent.

Mothers of color report higher rates of depression. A mother’s mental health can impact her baby’s brain development and the healthy attachment between parent and child, which can affect the child’s physical and mental health and ability to learn. About 12 percent of babies have mothers with a history of depression. In 2010, African-American (18 percent) and American Indian (28 percent) mothers had significantly higher rates of reported depression prior to pregnancy.

Early Head Start and Head Start are serving more children than ever before but cannot keep up with the growth of eligible children in poverty. In 2013, Early Head Start and Head Start had enough slots to enroll about 19 percent of children under age 6 in poverty, and the School Readiness Program served approximately 13 percent of the 3, 4, and pre-K 5 year olds in the state.

Children of color have higher rates of out-of-home placement. In 2011, about 3,000 children under age 6 were in out-of-home placement or foster care, with large disparities for American Indian and Black children. Often this is a result of reported abuse and neglect, which is also highest among American Indian and Black children.

Children from lower-income families, Latino children, and American Indian children have the lowest rates of kindergarten readiness. In 2010, 60 percent of Minnesota’s kindergartners demonstrated readiness for school. While the percentage is higher than in the three prior years, when 52 to 54 percent reached overall proficiency, it is important to note that only about half of low-income children under age 6 are ready.

This first School Readiness Report Card provides the opportunity to advance our conversations and actions, progressing from documenting the disparities in access to resources and well-being among children under age 6 to understanding these differences as avoidable and unjust.

Achieving the goal that all children are ready for kindergarten by the year 2020 requires targeted investments in multi-generational, comprehensive, and flexible services for early learning, health, and family support and greater economic development among Minnesota’s diverse communities. It also requires valuing diversity and equity for all children, families, and communities and eliminating systemic and structural inequities based on race and racism. Equity and inclusion must be integral to our actions and to how we define and measure service access, family and community engagement, program quality, and early childhood outcomes.

Unless we address these concerns now, the inequities will grow, and kindergarten readiness efforts will likely fail.

This first School Readiness Report Card was developed to monitor the state’s progress toward the goal that all children are ready for kindergarten by the year 2020. It consists of six fact sheets that include indicators of progress for both systems and child outcomes. Together they provide a comprehensive picture of Minnesota children under age 6. Trends are examined in the early childhood population, early care and education, health and development, and family support.

Richard Chase is a Senior Research Manager at Wilder Research. Richard studies early childhood policies, services, and indicators and evaluates the effectiveness of school readiness, prevention, and capacity-building programs for children, youth, and families.

Opinions expressed in Minnesota Compass guest columns do not necessarily reflect the views of Minnesota Compass. Compass welcomes a range of views about issues pertaining to quality of life in Minnesota.

Featured trend

Percentage of Minnesota adults age 25 or older with a bachelor's degree

Educational attainment among Minnesota’s adults continues to rise

Minnesota ranks among the 10 states with the highest shares of college-educated adults. Today, 37% of adults in Minnesota have a bachelor’s degree or higher, an increase of almost 10 percentage points since 2000.

See our educational attainment key measure for more on this topic.


Data Update


There are 20 counties in Minnesota in which at least one in five young children (age 0-5) lives in poverty

Foreign-born populations continue to grow as a proportion of the overall population, making up 9% of Minnesota’s population, up from 7% in 2010.

Approximately 38% of householders of color pay too much for housing.

The ratio of retirement-age adults (65+) to working-age adults (16-64) increased in 60 Minnesota cities, signaling disproportionate growth in the number of older adults compared to the working-age population.

Between 2016 and 2019, the share of Minnesota students who report being highly engaged in enrichment activities fell from 65% to nearly 60%.